Two equal shareholders in a Gauteng contract-cleaning company decided to part ways. Verance valued the business at R8.93 million, which put the exiting shareholder’s 50% at R4.46 million on paper. After allocating the company’s debts fairly between the two shareholders, we structured a settlement-adjusted offer of R2.18 million: R500,000 upfront and the balance over 36 months at 6% interest. The deal went through, and the continuing shareholder took full ownership with a payment plan the business could carry.
Snapshot
| Business | Contract cleaning and facilities services company, Gauteng, trading since 2007 |
| Size | Revenue R28.2 million (FY2025), up from R15.3 million two years earlier |
| Ownership | Two shareholders, 50% each, both directors |
| Decision | One shareholder buying out the other |
| Verance’s role | Independent valuation, indicative offer and deal structure, coordinating the sale-of-shares agreement |
| Valuation | R8.93 million (DCF), about 3.3× EBITDA versus net asset value of R1.99 million |
| Settlement | R2.18 million for the 50% stake, staged over 36 months |
| Valuation fee | R17,500 excl. VAT |
| Outcome | Deal concluded. Effective date 1 July 2026 |
The situation
The company provides daily office cleaning, consumables replenishment, waste coordination and deep-cleaning services to commercial property owners and corporate tenants, mostly on recurring monthly contracts. It had grown fast: revenue rose from R15.3 million in FY2023 to R26.8 million in FY2024 and R28.2 million in FY2025.
The two founding shareholders had reached the point where one wanted to exit and the other wanted to carry on. They needed to agree three things:
- What is the business actually worth?
- What is a fair price for a 50% stake?
- How can the continuing shareholder pay for it without starving the business of cash?
The challenge: why the headline value wasn’t the cheque
Contract cleaning is a labour-intensive, thin-margin industry. That shaped everything about this valuation.
- Thin margins. Employment costs were about R20.3 million of R28.2 million in revenue. Net profit was R410,000, a net margin of about 1.5%, which is typical for compliant operators competing against informal under-pricing.
- Working-capital pressure. Wages are paid monthly but clients pay in 45 to 60 days. The company was using R1.99 million of a R2.6 million overdraft, and operating cash flow was negative in the two most recent years.
- Debts that would stay behind. Besides the overdraft, the company carried a SARS VAT debt of R1.22 million under a payment arrangement, a short-term business loan of R342,000 and a R408,800 loan owed to the continuing shareholder.
The real question wasn’t only “what is the company worth?” It was “what is the exiting shareholder’s share worth, once you account for obligations the remaining shareholder will have to carry alone?”
Our approach
1. Understand the business, not just the numbers
We gathered information across seven areas (financial, operational, governance, risk, people, strategy and compliance), not just the financial statements. That included contracts, lease terms, fleet and equipment, tax compliance status, facility limits and loan balances.
2. Normalise earnings
We analysed four years of results to separate sustainable earnings from once-off items, and confirmed unadjusted EBITDA of R928,000 for FY2025.
3. Score the risk, factor by factor
Rather than applying a generic industry discount rate, we rated 20 business-specific risk factors on a three-tier scale. These included debtor collection, client concentration, contract-termination risk, labour relations, key-person dependence and reputation. The weighted result was a risk premium of 25.8%, giving a discount rate of 31.8%. That rate is high, and it honestly reflects a labour-heavy, overdraft-funded SME.
4. Value it three ways
- Discounted Cash Flow (primary): R8.93 million
- Net Asset Value (floor): R1.99 million
- Earnings multiple (cross-check): the DCF value equates to about 3.3× EBITDA, a sensible level for a small, owner-managed services business
The fair recommended value was R8.93 million, or R89,260 per share on 100 issued shares.
From valuation to offer
A valuation report tells you what the business is worth. It is not a settlement schedule. So we prepared a non-binding indicative offer on behalf of the continuing shareholder to bridge the two.
Step 1: Gross value of the stake
| Total equity value | R8,926,000 |
| × 50% shareholding | R4,463,000 |
Step 2: Allocate the company’s obligations 50/50
Because the continuing shareholder would carry these obligations alone after the exit, half of each was deducted from the exiting shareholder’s value:
| Adjustment | Total | 50% deducted |
|---|---|---|
| Bank overdraft facility | R2,600,000 | (R1,300,000) |
| SARS VAT debt | R1,222,498 | (R611,249) |
| Loan owed to continuing shareholder | R408,800 | (R204,400) |
| Short-term business loan | R341,979 | (R170,989) |
| Settlement-adjusted value | R2,176,562 |
Rounded, this gave a purchase consideration of R2,180,000, about 49% of the gross pro-rata value. That isn’t a “discount” on the valuation. It is the same value, adjusted for what each shareholder walks away with and walks away from.
Step 3: Make it affordable
Paying R2.18 million in one lump sum would have pushed the company further into its overdraft. Instead we proposed:
- R500,000 on signature or transfer
- R1,680,000 over 36 months, at 6% per year on the outstanding balance (about R51,100 a month)
- Clear terms for early settlement, late payment and default
Step 4: Protect both sides
The offer also set out:
- the exiting shareholder’s resignation as director and a clean break on all shareholder claims
- non-solicitation of clients and staff for an agreed period
- conditions precedent: verifying the share register, overdraft, SARS balance and loan accounts, and confirming no undisclosed liabilities
- that any future consulting role for the seller would be agreed separately, not hidden in the price
Getting to signature
Once both shareholders accepted the offer in principle, Verance coordinated a commercial attorney to draft the sale-of-shares agreement, share transfer documents, director resignation, resolutions and a closing checklist. All the agreed terms were carried in: payment schedule, interest, default provisions and the treatment of the overdraft, VAT debt and loans.
The transaction went through with an effective date of 1 July 2026.
What happened next
With ownership settled, the continuing shareholder turned to the issues the valuation had exposed: thin margins, overdraft reliance and the SARS repayment plan. Verance proposed a six-month turnaround and profitability programme focused on contract-level profitability, cost leakage, debtor collection and a 12–24 month plan to reduce debt. The aim is to move the business from its valuation baseline to a stronger value position.
Lessons for owners going through a shareholder buy-out
- Gross value isn’t take-home value. In a partial buy-out, company debts and shareholder loans change what is fair for each party. Agree how they’ll be treated early.
- Price and payment terms are separate levers. A fair price paid on unaffordable terms can sink the business you’re buying into. Staged payments with interest can work for both sides.
- Use a risk-based discount rate, not a rule of thumb. A business-specific risk assessment makes the value defensible when the other party pushes back.
- Put it in writing in stages. A non-binding indicative offer, then a formal sale-of-shares agreement. Verify balances before you sign.
- Use the valuation as a management tool. The same analysis that sets the price shows where value is leaking.
Frequently asked questions
How do you value a 50% shareholding in a private company?
Start by valuing 100% of the business using recognised methods (usually DCF, cross-checked to net asset value and earnings multiples). Then take the pro-rata share, and adjust for anything the two shareholders should carry differently: company debts, shareholder loans and tax exposures.
Is a 50% stake worth exactly half the company?
On paper, a 50% stake in a two-shareholder company is often valued pro-rata. In settlement, however, the net amount can differ substantially once obligations that stay with the continuing shareholder are allocated, as this case shows.
How much does a shareholder buy-out valuation cost?
For an SME with revenue of R5 million to R50 million, typically R12,000 to R19,000 excl. VAT. This engagement was R17,500. See our business valuation cost guide.
Can the buy-out price be paid over time?
Yes. Staged payments with interest on the outstanding balance are common in SME buy-outs. They should be documented with clear default and early-settlement terms.
Facing a shareholder exit or buy-out?
Verance provides independent valuations and transaction support for South African businesses, from first valuation to signed agreement.
Book an introductory callRequest a proposal
2 Comments
Comments are closed.